Deciding whether to sell now
Before anything else, it is worth sitting down with real numbers on three things: how much equity you likely have, what your next move looks like, and whether the timing works for your life. Equity is roughly what your home would sell for, minus what you still owe and the costs of selling — our seller net worksheet further down walks through that math on an example sale.
Think through where you are going next and whether that purchase depends on this sale closing first, or whether you have flexibility to buy first, sell first, or do both closer together. And think honestly about timing — the season, your own schedule for showings and moving, and whether current market conditions in your area favor sellers, buyers, or neither. None of these has one right answer; they are simply worth working through before you list, not after.
What actually determines price
The price a home is likely to sell for comes down to a handful of things working together: recent sales of genuinely comparable homes nearby, the home's condition and updates relative to those comparables, its specific location — even within the same town, a lot on a busy road or backing to commercial property prices differently than a quiet cul-de-sac — and what else is currently competing for the same buyers. A home priced against last year's market, or against a neighbor's sale from a different condition and year, is being priced against the wrong data.
Online home-value estimates are a reasonable starting point for a very rough sense of value, and nothing more. They are generated from public records and algorithms that cannot see your kitchen, your roof's age, or the work you have done — they routinely miss meaningfully on individual homes. An accurate price comes from an in-person walk-through and a genuine comparison to homes that have actually sold nearby, which is exactly what we do before recommending a list price.
Preparing the home
Not every repair pays for itself at sale. Structural issues, active leaks, and safety hazards are worth addressing before you list, because they scare off buyers and complicate inspections later. Cosmetic wear that a buyer can easily picture fixing — a dated paint color, worn but sound carpet — is much lower priority, and pouring money into a full remodel rarely returns what it costs. Talk through your specific home with us before spending on repairs; what is worth doing varies a lot by property and price point.
Decluttering and depersonalizing consistently help, and cost nothing but time: buyers need to be able to picture their own life in the space, which is harder with a full display of family photos, a crowded garage, or rooms full of furniture. Curb appeal matters more than people expect, since it sets a buyer's first impression before they walk in the door — mowed grass, trimmed bushes, a clean and decluttered porch, and a freshly painted front door go a long way for very little cost.
A realistic pre-listing checklist:
- Fix anything broken, leaking, or unsafe
- Deep clean, including carpets and windows
- Declutter closets, counters, and the garage
- Remove excess personal photos and collections
- Mow, trim, and clear the yard and walkways
- Touch up or repaint scuffed walls and trim
- Replace burned-out bulbs and check smoke detectors
- Address obvious odors — pets, smoke, cooking
Photography and marketing
Most buyers form their first impression of your home online, long before they ever request a showing, which is why photography matters as much as it does. Well-lit, well-composed photos, taken after the home is cleaned and staged, are worth the effort — they are usually the single biggest factor in whether a buyer stops scrolling and clicks in.
Once listed, your home reaches buyers through the local Multiple Listing Service, which is how virtually every active agent in the area sees new listings the moment they go live, and then syndicates out to the larger home-search sites buyers browse directly. Beyond that baseline reach, marketing can include a yard sign, an open house if that fits the property, social media posts, and outreach to agents who have buyers actively looking in your price range or area.
Showings and feedback
Once your home is live, showings are typically scheduled through a showing service or directly with your agent, with as much advance notice as you can reasonably give buyers' agents. Keeping the home consistently show-ready for the first couple of weeks matters, since that early window usually draws the most traffic and the most serious buyers.
We follow up after showings for feedback whenever we can get it — not every agent responds, but the feedback we do collect helps confirm whether your price and presentation are landing the way you expect, or whether something needs adjusting.
Reading an offer beyond the price
The offer price is the headline number, but it is far from the whole picture. We walk through every offer with you looking at the full package: the buyer's financing type (a cash offer, a conventional loan, or a government-backed loan like FHA, VA, or USDA each carry different timelines and requirements), the contingencies attached (financing, inspection, appraisal, sometimes a home-sale contingency tied to the buyer's own house), the requested possession date, the proposed closing date, and who is being asked to pay which closing costs.
A slightly lower offer with strong financing, fewer contingencies, and a workable timeline can sometimes be a better deal than a higher offer that is shakier or slower — this is exactly the kind of trade-off we help you weigh, term by term, rather than looking at price alone.
Inspection requests and how to negotiate repairs
After the buyer's inspection, expect a request that falls somewhere between "nothing" and a long list — most fall in between, focused on safety issues and major systems. You generally have several ways to respond: make the requested repairs yourself before closing, offer a credit toward the buyer's closing costs instead of doing the work, negotiate a middle ground on specific items, or decline and see whether the buyer still wants to proceed under the terms of your contract.
Try not to take an inspection request personally — buyers are often coached by their own agent to ask for more than they expect to get, and a level-headed, itemized response usually keeps the deal moving. We negotiate this on your behalf and will tell you plainly which requests are reasonable and which are not.
Appraisal
If your buyer is financing the purchase, their lender will order an independent appraisal to confirm the home supports the loan amount. Most appraisals come in at or above the contract price when a home has been priced correctly against real comparable sales. If one comes in low, the paths forward are the same ones a buyer would consider: you can lower the price to match, the buyer can bring extra cash to cover the gap, you can split the difference, or the buyer can exit if they kept an appraisal contingency. We will help you evaluate the appraisal and your options if this comes up.
Closing day
By closing day, most of the real work is done — the paperwork has been reviewed, any repairs or credits from inspection are settled, and the buyer's loan has cleared underwriting. As the seller, plan to bring a valid photo ID, all keys, garage remotes, and any codes or access items for the property, and to sign the deed and closing paperwork, typically at the title company's office. Any outstanding mortgage on the property is paid off from your proceeds at closing, along with agreed-upon closing costs and the commission set out in your listing agreement, and the balance is disbursed to you.
Seller net worksheet
Here is a rough shape of what nets out at closing, shown on an example $220,000 sale. These are examples only — your actual net depends on your loan payoff, your negotiated commission, and the specific costs on your transaction. Run your own numbers on our seller net-proceeds calculator.
| Item | Example | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Estimated sale price | $220,000 | Based on comparable sales, not an online estimate |
| Existing mortgage payoff | − | Get a current payoff figure from your lender or servicer |
| Real estate commission | − | Negotiated and agreed in your listing agreement |
| Title & closing fees (seller's share) | − | Set by the title company and what you negotiate with the buyer |
| Prorated property taxes | − or + | Split based on your closing date |
| Negotiated repairs or credits | − | Depends on what comes out of inspection |
| Estimated net proceeds | = | What you walk away with before your own move |
A note on commissions
Commissions are negotiable. They are not set by law, by any Realtor association, or by the MLS. The commission on your sale is whatever you and your broker agree to in writing in your listing agreement, and any figure you see referenced anywhere on this site is an example only, not a quote. Ask us directly what our services cost and what is included — we would rather explain it plainly than have you guess.
Indiana-specific paperwork
Selling a home in Indiana involves a couple of state-specific pieces of paperwork beyond the purchase agreement itself. Sellers generally complete a residential real estate Sales Disclosure Form as part of the transfer, along with a seller's disclosure describing the known condition of the property. The exact forms, requirements, and any exemptions change from time to time and can depend on the type of sale, so we confirm the current versions and requirements with you directly rather than relying on a general description like this one.
Closings here typically involve a title company handling the title search, closing documents, and disbursement of funds. Your broker and the title company you use are the right people to confirm current form versions, timing, and any local requirements specific to your sale.
Recently sold by our team
A look at homes we have recently helped sell in the area — a useful check on real, closed results rather than an online estimate.
We do not have recently sold listings to show right now. Call (812) 523-3914 and we can talk through recent sales in your neighborhood directly.
Frequently asked questions
How do you come up with a list price?
By comparing your home to recently sold homes that are genuinely similar in size, condition, location, and features, then adjusting for what is different about yours, and looking at what is currently competing for the same buyers.
Is an online home value estimate accurate?
It is a rough starting point at best. Those tools cannot see your home's actual condition or updates and routinely miss meaningfully on individual properties. An in-person walk-through and a real comparison to sold homes gets you a far more accurate number.
What is commission, and can I negotiate it?
It is the fee you agree to pay your broker for selling your home, and yes — it is negotiable and set in writing in your listing agreement. It is never fixed by law or by any Realtor association.
Do I have to make repairs before listing?
Not necessarily. Safety issues and major system problems are usually worth addressing; cosmetic wear often is not. We can walk your specific home and tell you what is likely to matter to buyers and what is not worth the money.
What if the buyer's inspection turns up problems?
You will typically get a request to make repairs, offer a credit, or some mix of the two. You are not obligated to agree to everything asked; we negotiate this with you item by item.
What if the appraisal comes in low?
You and the buyer have a few options — adjust the price, have the buyer bring extra cash, split the difference, or let the buyer exit if they kept an appraisal contingency. See the appraisal section above.
What Indiana-specific paperwork do I need to sign?
Generally a Sales Disclosure Form and a seller's disclosure of property condition, in addition to the purchase agreement. We confirm the current forms and requirements with you and the title company for your specific sale.
How long does it take to close after I accept an offer?
It depends heavily on the buyer's financing — a cash sale can close in a couple of weeks, while a financed purchase more commonly takes four to six weeks from accepted offer to closing.